The EB-5 program offers developers another funding option.
the broader economy is still seeking firm footing, commercial real estate
appears to be among the early engines of growth. Sustaining momentum in
property markets comes with the ever-present challenge to secure funding, as
lending and capital markets continue to remain tight.
— particularly those willing to take advantage of sophisticated financing or
complicated structures — are not without additional funding options, however.
Development in significantly challenged markets such as Cleveland and New
Orleans has remained consistent in recent years due to broad application of new
markets and historic tax credit-backed funding. Additionally, a newer
government-backed program known as EB-5 has shown stunning signs of growth and
offers hope to developers seeking new funding sources.
What Is EB-5?
as a part of the Immigration Act of 1990, the EB-5 immigration visa program
permits foreign nationals to qualify for permanent residency in the U.S. under
the employment-based fifth preference category — hence the name. Through the
EB-5 program, foreign nationals who invest a minimum of $1 million in U.S.
businesses can receive green cards for themselves and
their immediate family, if the investment is made in a business that thereafter
creates at least 10 full-time jobs. The minimum investment amount is reduced to
$500,000 if the investment is made in a business located in a “targeted
employment area” — a rural area or an urban area with an unemployment rate that
is at least 150 percent of the national average.
investment activities are typically coordinated by, and project funding and
investment is often operated through, one of the almost 300 regional centers
designated by the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services agency. These centers
focus on specific geographic areas and work to promote economic growth through
increased exports and productivity and job creation.
the EB-5 program has evolved, both equity and loan models of investment have
been developed. The equity model refers to projects where a regional center,
along with the foreign investors, takes direct ownership in the business or
property. On exit, after the minimum five-year holding period, the investors
elect to sell either the business or their equity interest and/or dissolve the
the loan model typically involves the investors and regional center creating a
stand-alone entity, which then makes a loan to the subject business or
property. The loan exit occurs following the maturity date, usually based on a
the program has prospered, the loan model has become more prevalent due to the
relative certainty as to exit modes and timing — when the loan is paid off.
With the equity model, exit timing and costs are susceptible to market forces.
If a developer wants to buy out the investors, the costs could escalate if the
project is particularly successful.
investments can be used for almost any commercial real estate project; however,
all projects utilizing EB-5 funds must be reviewed by USCIS. It is not unusual
for funds to not be available for up to 12 months following the initial
closing. EB-5 investments must weave through a lengthy review process that
evaluates both the project and the investors. The review includes analysis and
due diligence on the project, the business, and the company business plan.
the lead time to funding also encompasses negotiation and execution of the
investment documents between the project sponsor and the regional center;
marketing of the investment opportunity overseas; securing of foreign
investment funds; application, review, and processing of investor visa
applications; and, finally, delivery of investment proceeds to the project. To
be clear, whether EB-5 project investments are made through loan or equity
model, such investments will pool funds from multiple investors and the overall
number of investors is limited only by the aggregate size of the investment
(keeping the applicable minimum investment requirements in mind, however).
both the project and an investor are approved by USCIS, the investor receives a
conditional two-year green card. The investor and immediate family can apply
for permanent residency based on the EB-5 investment. If approved, EB-5 investors
then become permanent green card holders and can later apply to become U.S.
citizens. Upon receipt of conditional permanent resident status, investors and
their immediate families are entitled to the same benefits as other lawful
eligible projects, the EB-5 program offers developers access to diversified
project funding. Whether through a debt-based or equity-based model, EB-5 can
help developers close funding gaps, increase capital stacks, or expand equity.
Other than the $1 million investment requirement (or $500,000 in applicable
geographic locations), there is no definitive minimum investment required. The
time and costs involved in securing funds and approvals, however, may create
cost inefficiencies for projects requiring less than $5 million in funds. But
sponsors of large development projects, particularly those with lengthy lead or
build times, may find significant benefits and financing cost savings using
course, as with most evolving programs, the EB-5 standards and rules remain
fluid. Developers should be sure to consult with qualified counsel to ensure
the developer’s interests are well protected and overall project compliance is
Goss is a partner in the Real Estate
Practice Group of Cleveland-based Walter Haverfield. Contact him at email@example.com.